Car insurance renewal price went up? What the FCA rules allow
Since 1 January 2022, FCA rules require insurers to offer renewing home and motor insurance customers a price no higher than they would pay as a new customer through the same channel, so loyalty alone can no longer push your premium up. Your renewal can still rise if prices rise for everyone, and it can still be beaten by another insurer, so the quote is worth checking every year.

Photo: frankieleon, Flickr, CC BY 2.0
Before the rules, many insurers raised the price for existing customers at each renewal, a practice the FCA calls price walking. The ban changed what you can expect, but not the need to compare. Spot double cover and what you pay above the usual price.
What the rule says
The FCA’s general insurance pricing rules, in force since 1 January 2022, cover home and motor insurance and the add-ons sold with them:
- your renewal quote must be no higher than the equivalent new business price, meaning what the same insurer would quote you as a new customer through the same sales channel;
- most consumers got easier ways to cancel auto-renewal;
- insurers must show they offer fair value and report pricing data to the FCA.
1 January 2022
Check whether your renewal looks out of line with what new customers pay.
Check my renewal quoteHas it worked?
The FCA’s July 2025 evaluation looked at the home insurance market. Before the reforms, an existing policyholder paid on average £95.38 more than a new customer. After them, the gap almost halved, to £49.17. The FCA says the differences that remain are not necessarily a sign of widespread price walking, and that it has investigated individual firms where gaps showed up.
Before the rules, its 2020 market study had found that in 2018, 6 million loyal policyholders would have saved £1.2 billion had they paid the average price for their actual risk. See whether you are paying above the usual price.
See if I am overpayingWhy your renewal can still go up
The rule ties you to the new-customer price, which moves:
- market prices: if claims and repair costs push up prices for new customers, renewals follow;
- your risk: a claim, a conviction, a new address, a new car or a younger named driver change the price for anyone with your profile;
- the channel: the comparison is with the same channel. A price on a comparison site can differ from the insurer’s own website.
So a higher renewal is not automatically a breach. It is a signal to compare with other insurers. Compare your quote with the market.
Compare my car insuranceHome insurance: the same rule
Everything above applies to home insurance too: buildings, contents, or both. The FCA’s evaluation figures come from the home market, where the gap between renewing and new customers shrank the most visibly. If you renew home and car insurance with the same insurer, check each renewal separately against its own new-customer price, since the two policies are priced independently.
The rule also covers add-ons sold with the policy, such as legal expenses, home emergency or key cover: at renewal, each must cost no more than it would for a new customer. What the rule cannot judge is whether you need the add-on at all: that question is yours.
Check my home insurance renewalA good habit is to keep last year’s renewal notice and this year’s side by side: if the premium rose and your details did not change, ask the insurer what changed in its prices, and compare with at least two other quotes before you accept.
Compare my home and car renewalsWhat to do when the renewal arrives
- Read the renewal notice and last year’s premium next to it.
- Check your details: mileage, address, job, parking, named drivers. A wrong detail can raise the price or cause problems when you claim.
- Get quotes from other insurers, through comparison sites and directly, a few weeks before the renewal date.
- Call your insurer with the best offer: the FCA notes that consumers can still benefit from negotiating with their current provider.
- Turn off auto-renewal if you plan to switch, and confirm the old policy ends on the day the new one starts.
Get your renewal checklist ready before the date.
Get my renewal checklistPaying for cover twice
Renewals are also the moment to remove overlaps. Breakdown cover can come with a bank account, legal expenses with home insurance, and courtesy car or windscreen cover as add-ons you may already have elsewhere. Each add-on renewal falls under the same price rule as the main policy, but it still costs money if you do not need it. Find the cover you pay for twice.
Find my duplicate coverFrequently asked questions
Can my insurer charge me more for renewing than a new customer?
No. Since 1 January 2022, a home or motor insurer must offer you a renewal price no higher than it would quote you as a new customer through the same channel, such as its website or a comparison site.
Why did my car insurance go up at renewal?
The rule stops price walking, not price rises. If the insurer charges new customers with your profile more this year, because of claims costs, your area, your car or your own claims, your renewal can go up too.
Is it still worth shopping around for car insurance?
Yes. The rule compares you with the same insurer’s new customers, not with other insurers. The FCA itself says consumers can still benefit from shopping around or negotiating with their current provider.
Can I cancel auto-renewal on my insurance?
Yes. The FCA’s 2022 package also gave most consumers easier ways to cancel the automatic renewal of their home or motor policy.
Sources
- Financial Conduct Authority, FCA confirms measures to protect customers from the loyalty penalty in home and motor insurance markets (28 May 2021), accessed 22 November 2026
- Financial Conduct Authority, EP25/2: An evaluation of our General Insurance Pricing Practices remedies (July 2025), accessed 22 November 2026
Read next
Everyday moneyCancel broadband mid contract after a price rise: when it is free
Photo: krossbow, Flickr, CC BY 2.0
Everyday moneyCar finance claim: who is owed compensation and how to claim
Photo: Sister72, Flickr, CC BY 2.0
Everyday moneyUK inflation rate: 3.6% in October 2026, and what it costs you
Photo: Amsterdam free photos & pictures of the Dutch city, Flickr, CC0